If we open a quarrel between the past and the present, we shall find that we have lost the future.
– Winston Churchill
“The flash crash” on the 5th of August is likely the event during the month that most investors consider the most memorable; however, perhaps the dramatic revision to the reported number of jobs created by the US economy will prove to be the most significant. On August 21st, The Washington Post headlined, “Labor Market Was Weaker Than Previously Reported in Big Fix to Data,” with the second sentence of the accompanying article reading, “The government reported Wednesday that the economy created 818,000 fewer jobs from April 2023 through March 2024 in the biggest revision to federal jobs data in 15 years, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.”
In recent months, commentators have been grappling with the apparent disconnect between the reported robust condition of the US economy and the increasing negativity of the US population’s attitude toward that same economy. As the rate of inflation declined and the US economy provided ample opportunities for employment, the University of Michigan’s Current Economic Conditions Index rose to 82.5 by March 2024. In the following five months, it fell to 61.3, a decline of 25%. Almost half of those in the workforce are employed by small businesses with fewer than five hundred employees. Larger businesses secure their capital in the bond market for longer terms and have been significantly shielded from rising interest rates. Small businesses, however, predominantly borrow from regional banks at current interest rates, which are now near 8%. Consequently, there has been no increase in bank loans to businesses year over year. Small businesses with fewer than fifty employees have experienced a zero-growth rate in employment on a year-over-year basis, and the rate of new business formations has declined by 51%. It is possible that a number of widely held assumptions about the true state of our economy are on the verge of being significantly altered.
In the pre-pandemic world of the 2010s, the 10-Year US Treasury rate averaged 2.41%, the Fed Funds Rate was 0.75%, and the US Consumer Price Index stood at 1.78%. Most anticipated that this state of reality would likely persist. Then came the federal government’s public policy response to the pandemic, resulting in inflation levels reaching 9% in June 2022 and the Federal Reserve hiking interest rates to 5.50% in July 2023, where they currently remain. In the past three months, the Core CPI Rate, which excludes food and energy due to the volatility of those specific inputs, has fallen to an annualized rate of 1.60%, below the Fed’s 2% target.
The US Federal Reserve has what is referred to as a twin mandate: to maintain an inflation rate of 2% and a level of economic activity sufficient to support the full employment of the US workforce. The Fed Funds rate is the interest rate it uses to influence the rate of economic activity. The “neutral” Fed Funds Rate is thought by many economists to be 2.75%. Currently, the rate stands at 5.50%. If the economy is no longer at full employment and the inflation rate is approaching 2%, then that rate should find its way to 2.75% and possibly much sooner than most expect. Thus far, this part of the picture is reasonably clear; however, there is another aspect that seems to not be actively considered. The current Ten-Year US Treasury rate is 3.84%. The break-even rate, as identified by the Treasury Inflation Protected Security (TIPS) market, is 2.15%, close to the pre-pandemic rate. Let’s propose a possible scenario: we are returning to our pre-pandemic world with a Fed Funds rate of 0.75%, a CPI rate of 1.78%, and 10-Year US Treasury rates of 2.41%. For those arguing that this is not possible, a reasonable response would be to ask what has changed that would prevent it from becoming so?
With the Federal Reserve poised to take its foot off the brake that is negatively impacting half of our national economy, the effect of materially lower interest rates could be significantly more positive than is widely assumed. The news could be especially good for prospective home buyers. Historically, the yield spread between thirty-year fixed-rate mortgages and the ten-year US Treasury rate is 1.50%. That spread is currently at 2.50%. With mortgage rates currently at 6.50%, it may be that 5% rates could be in our not-too-distant future. Stock market investors may also be buoyed by the prospects of rising valuations due to lower interest rates and an economy that starts to regain its stride with borrowing rates that become increasingly affordable.
Recovering nicely from “the flash crash” of August 5th, the S&P 500 was +2.43% for the month and +19.52% year to date, but it was a very different market with “the Magnificent 7” stocks at -0.70% for the month, while defensive sectors of the market such as Consumer Staples, Real Estate, Utilities, and Health Care posted returns twice that of the index.
Mid-cap stocks were flat, and small-cap was -1.44%. Foreign developed markets matched the S&P, with European stocks and Latin American stocks performing particularly well. The curious disconnect between gold and cryptocurrencies continues, with gold at +2.31% and Bitcoin at -8.84%. The 60/40 portfolio returned 1.12% for the month, with the 60% equity share returning 2.35% and the 40% fixed income share flat, resulting in portfolio returns now at +13.2% year to date.
Mark H. Tekamp